Three out of four caregivers will leave their jobs this year. The reflex is to blame recruiting. The real constraint is a Medicaid rate that cannot fund the wage required to keep them. You cannot exhort your way out of arithmetic.

Three out of four caregivers will quit this year.

That is not a Wake County failure. It is a national condition. The Activated Insights 2024 Home Care Benchmarking Report put turnover at 79.2% in 2023, the highest since 2018. The 2025 edition, published July 1, 2025, found it had fallen to 75%, the lowest level the report has recorded in the past five years. Either number means the same thing in a Raleigh living room: of every ten caregivers an agency employs today, fewer than three will still be there next year.

And most of the leaving happens fast. Nearly four out of five caregivers who quit do so within their first 100 days. The problem is not veteran aides burning out after a decade. It is a pipeline that loses people before they ever become reliable.

That is the story everyone in home care already knows.

Here is the part almost no one says out loud.

Demand is not the variable. It is the certainty.

Every projection points the same direction, and the direction is up.

Wake County is adding roughly 51 residents a day, one of the fastest growth rates of any large county in the country (WRAL / U.S. Census Bureau). In Cary, about 15.5% of residents are already 65 or older. Geriatric patients now make up roughly a third of WakeMed’s entire system volume. In February 2024, WakeMed Cary became the county’s first Level 1 accredited Geriatric Emergency Department, an institution betting capital on exactly this curve.

The labor to serve that curve is not keeping pace. North Carolina’s Department of Commerce projects 14,600 net new home health and personal care aide positions statewide by 2030, and that counts growth only. Add the replacement openings that 75-79% turnover generates, and NC DHHS estimates roughly 182,400 direct care job openings by 2030; PHI National puts it at 207,100 across 2022–2032. The Bureau of Labor Statistics calls the occupation “much faster than average,” at 17% growth through 2034. More than 40% of all projected NC healthcare job growth this decade is in home- and community-based care: not hospitals, not nursing homes.

The shortage visible today is not the peak of the problem. It is the floor.

Now the part no one says: it is a math problem

The standard advice is one word. Pay more.

It is not wrong. The competitive wage floor for caregivers in Wake County is $17 to $20 an hour (Activated Insights; BLS). For reference, food-prep and service workers in the Raleigh-Cary metro average $17.32 an hour (BLS, May 2024). Triangle caregivers are routinely asked to accept less than the drive-through pays, for work that is physical, emotionally heavy, and performed alone in a stranger’s home. Of course they leave.

But here is the wall the advice runs into.

For Medicaid personal care, the state now reimburses $7.03 per 15 minutes, $28.12 an hour, effective August 1, 2026, under the 2026 Appropriations Act. Pay a caregiver $20 of that, add the employer’s share of payroll taxes and workers’ compensation, roughly 18 percent, and the margin before overhead grows to about $4.52 an hour. The delivered rate also came in $0.47 per unit, $1.88 per hour, below the $7.50 many providers had planned around. Under the prior $23.84 rate, that same math left $0.24. (HCIG analysis, directional; the exact margin varies by agency.)

So when an agency pays below the wage that would retain caregivers, that is not greed. It is the rational response to a rate that does not fund the wage. The turnover everyone laments is, in part, a designed outcome of the reimbursement structure.

That is the intelligence. The shortage is not a failure of agency will. It is arithmetic.

And it is not only the low-wage end. Private Duty Nursing (skilled in-home care) pays $52 an hour, the highest Medicaid home rate in the state (NC DHHS). It still goes unstaffed, because the nursing labor pool is its own shortage: the Sheps Center projects NC registered-nurse demand to exceed supply by 18% in home health and hospice by 2033. Even the well-funded service cannot find the worker. Money alone does not conjure a labor pool that the broader market has already drained.

What an unstaffed authorization actually looks like

This is where the workforce story meets the discharge story from the other direction.

In hospital discharge, Wake County has no shortage of agencies; 447 of them are licensed. The failure there is conversion: referrals that never become visits. The constraint in this piece is the opposite layer. The agencies exist. The people who do the work do not.

HCIG analysis estimates 1,000 to 2,000 unfilled direct care positions across Wake, Durham, and Orange counties at any given moment, and that 10–20% of authorized Medicaid hours (PDN, CAP-DA, CAP-C) go unstaffed in the Triangle, not for lack of an approved care plan but for lack of anyone to staff it. (HCIG analysis applying the region’s population share to NC DHHS and Alliance Health data; directional, not counted.) A deficit of even 1,000 full-time-equivalent workers translates to 1.5 to 1.8 million authorized-but-undelivered service hours a year.

A family holding an approved CAP-DA plan with no caregiver to fill it is not a paperwork problem. It is a labor problem wearing a paperwork disguise.

The hidden invoice

Turnover does not show up as a line item, which is why it is underestimated. Activated Insights puts the cost of replacing one caregiver at roughly $2,600: recruiting, scheduler time, paid orientation, shadowing, early no-shows, and the revenue of cases declined because no one was available. A 100-caregiver agency running at 75% turnover replaces 75 people a year. That is close to $195,000 spent before a single additional client is served.

Agencies that pay below the floor are not saving money. They are paying the cost of churn instead, where it is harder to see.

For Hospital Systems and Discharge Planners

When an agency cannot staff your referral, it is often not unreliable; it is caught in the rate trap. Your most dependable post-acute partners are the ones investing in wages, onboarding, and scheduling stability now. Ask intake coordinators about caregiver tenure and fill rates, not just whether a slot is “available.” Stability is a clinical variable.

For MCO Leaders

An authorization is a promise the labor market may not keep. The 10-20% of hours going unstaffed is a network-adequacy gap that more authorizations will not close. Rate adequacy and wage pass-through are the levers; the question is whether your contracts measure delivered hours, not just approved ones.

For Investors

The moat in RTP home care is workforce infrastructure, not a license. There are 447 licenses and a scarce labor pool. The agencies that engineer retention (competitive wages, structured onboarding, predictable schedules) capture a demand curve that is steepening every year. The ones competing on price churn through both staff and clients.

For Policymakers and the NC General Assembly

The wage and the rate moved on different tracks, and only one has reached the caregiver so far. HB 1045, the Fair Wages in Health Care Act (filed April 23, 2026), would set an $18 an hour floor for home care aides and direct support professionals. It remains in committee. The PCS rate increase, first proposed in SB 366 (2025) and again in SB 896 (2026), reached law a different way. The 2026 Appropriations Act (Senate Bill 257, Section 9E.15) funded the increase, and NC Medicaid set PCS at $7.03 per 15 minutes, up from $5.96 ($23.84 to $28.12 an hour), effective August 1, 2026. The rate moved. The wage floor has not. Whether the increase reaches caregivers as higher pay, without a mandated wage floor forcing the pass-through, is the open question. HB 696’s $319 million Medicaid patch, signed into law April 30, 2026, covered a single fiscal year, which makes all of this a recurring decision, not a solved one.

The caregiver shortage will not be solved by asking agencies to try harder.

It will be solved when the rate funds the wage. Or it will not be solved at all.

A note on method

Figures attributed to a named source (BLS, NC DHHS, Activated Insights, NC Department of Commerce, PHI National, the Sheps Center, the NC General Assembly) are drawn from that publication and current as of May 2026. Regional estimates (unfilled positions, the share of unstaffed Medicaid hours, the per-hour margin) are HCIG analysis, explicitly flagged in the text. They are directional, not precise, and should not be cited as counted figures. Readers making operational or policy decisions should verify current rates and bill status with the primary source.

Sources

  1. Activated Insights, 2024 Home Care Benchmarking Report (formerly Home Care Pulse). Caregiver turnover 79.2% in 2023, highest since 2018.
  2. Activated Insights, 2025 Home Care Benchmarking Report, published July 1, 2025. Caregiver turnover 75%, the lowest level reported in the past five years; ~$2,600 average cost per departure; $17-$20 competitive wage floor; first-100-day attrition.
  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook – Home Health and Personal Care Aides, 2024–2034; and Raleigh-Cary Metro Occupational Employment and Wages, May 2024. ($17.32 mean food-prep wage; 17% projected growth.)
  4. NC Department of Commerce, North Carolina Employment Projections 2021-2030. (14,600 net new aide positions; 40%+ of healthcare growth in home/community-based care.)
  5. NC DHHS Division of Health Benefits. (~182,400 direct care openings by 2030; Direct Care Worker Survey, 2024.)
  6. PHI National, NC State Direct Care Workforce Profile, 2024–2025. (207,100 total direct care openings, 2022-2032.)
  7. NC DHHS, Personal Care Services Fee Schedule, updated December 31, 2025 ($5.96/15 min, superseded August 1, 2026); NC General Assembly, Senate Bill 257 (2026 Appropriations Act), signed July 7, 2026, PCS increased to $7.03/15 min ($28.12/hr); Medicaid Rate Schedule (PDN $52/hr).
  8. Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research (UNC), NC Nursing Workforce Projections. (RN demand to exceed NC supply by 18% in home health and hospice by 2033.)
  9. WRAL / U.S. Census Bureau, Wake County Population Growth Data, 2024. (51 new residents per day.)
  10. WakeMed, “WakeMed Cary Hospital Receives National Accreditation for Geriatric Emergency Care,” February 14, 2024.
  11. NC DHSR Home Care All Licensure List, 2026. (447 licensed Wake County agencies.)
  12. NC General Assembly: HB 696 / Session Law 2026-1 ($319M Medicaid funding, signed April 30, 2026); HB 1045, Fair Wages in Health Care Act (filed April 23, 2026; sets an $18/hr floor for home care aides and direct support professionals, $20 CNA, $22 psychiatric aide, $24 LPN); “Increase Medicaid PCS and PDN Rates” (introduced as SB 366, 2025, in Senate committee; The increase passed through the 2026 Appropriations Act, Senate Bill 257, Section 9E.15, not SB 366 or SB 896, for 2026-27: PCS to $7.03 per 15-minute unit. SB 896 also proposed raising PDN to $16.25 per 15 minutes; that bill remains in committee.)

Home Care Intelligence is the market intelligence platform of Home Care Intelligence Group, covering the Research Triangle home care market.

June 2026  |  Updated August 2026  |  7 minute read